Administrative responsibility for AI errors in digital public facilities and its impact on state stability: A comparative study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25130/jfa.conf.11.4.23Keywords:
Administrative responsibility, artificial intelligence, digital public utilities, digital transformation, state stability, administrative legitimacyAbstract
the rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies has significantly transformed the methods used in the management of public services. significant transformation in public utility management methods. Many countries now rely on smart digital systems to deliver public services more quickly, efficiently, and transparently. This transformation has given rise to the concept of digital public utilities, which leverage modern technology, data, and AI to achieve the goals of modern public administration.
his study examines the contribution of artificial intelligence (AI) to enhancing the management of public services digital public utilities. It begins by defining AI and its characteristics, clarifying the nature of digital public utilities, and highlighting their key applications in government services, healthcare, education, the judiciary, transportation, and smart cities. The research also explores administrative liability arising from errors that may occur when using AI systems, whether due to flaws in algorithms, data, or operational mechanisms, and the extent to which traditional administrative liability rules can be applied to these errors.
Furthermore, the research addresses the impact of AI errors on state stability by examining their effect on public utility performance, institutional trust, and legal security. Finally, it explores the requirements for digital governance and legislative reform to ensure the safe and responsible use of these technologies. This research adopted an analytical approach to examine rel
Downloads
References
Books
(1) Amal Jaballah, The Impact of Electronic Means on the Legality of Legal Administration Actions, 1st ed., Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami'i, Egypt, p. 35.
(2) Barak Ahmed Muhammad, The Problem of Criminal Liability for Artificial Intelligence Technologies, Legal Research Center, Erbil, Iraq, 2024.
)3) Hussam Rashid Hadi, The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the International System, Amjad Publishing and Distribution House, Amman, 2023.
(4) Hassan Al-Maamouri, Crisis Management in Complex Political Systems: Iraq as a Model, Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, 2021.
(5) Dr. Reda Mahmoud Al-Abd, Virtual Legal Personality: Towards Recognizing the Legal Personality of Robots Equipped with Artificial Intelligence, no publisher, 2024.
(6)Samir Dannoun, Personal and Institutional Error in Administrative and Civil Law, Al-Haditha Foundation for Books, 2009, p. 212.
(7) See Dr. Essam Al-Barzanji, Principles and Provisions of Administrative Law, Al-Atik Foundation for Book Production, Cairo, 2007.
(8)Dr. Abdul Raouf Hashem Muhammad Basyouni, The Theory of Error in the Field of Administrative Liability: A Comparative Study, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, 2005.
(9)Dr. Ali Jassim Al-Shammari, Digital Policy in the Middle East, Dar Al-Rafidain, Beirut, 2023, p. 112.
(10) Dr. Imad Ahmed Abu Saida, The Liability of the Direct and Indirect Responsibility, 1st ed., Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Amman, 2010.
(11) Dr. Abdul Razzaq Muhammad, General Theory of Administrative Law, Cairo: Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, 2014.
(12) Maher Saleh Alawi, Administrative Law, Dar Al-Hikma for Printing and Publishing, 1st ed., Baghdad, Iraq, 2001.
(13) Muhammad Abdullah Al-Fallah, Provisions of Administrative Law, 1st ed., Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami'i, 2016.
(14) Mazen Lilo Radi, Administrative Law, O.P.L.C. Foundation, Duhok, 2009.
(15) Hamin Hussein Hamad Amin, Moral Damage and Compensation for It in Administrative Law: A Comparative Study, Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Cairo, 1st ed., 2018.
Electronic Research
(1) Khadija Lotfi, How Can Artificial Intelligence Affect Education? Accessed on 25/7/2026 at 5:00 PM https://www.new-educ.com
(2) Shehata El-Sayed, Towards an Active Role for Internal Auditors in Managing Cybersecurity Risks in Companies Listed on the Egyptian Stock Exchange, Scientific Journal of Financial and Administrative Studies and Research, Volume 13, Issue 2, p. 26 et seq. http://search.mandumah.com/Record/1290731
(3) Mohamed Gawdat Saleh, Artificial Intelligence and Expert Systems, Article available at: www.fr.slideshare.net Accessed on 22/7/2026 at 12:00 AM.
Journals
(1) - Dr. (1) Osama, Mahrous, "Administrative Responsibility for Errors in Artificial Intelligence Applications," *The Legal Journal*, Volume 22, Issue 1, 2024.
(2)- Onisi Linda, "The Governing Principles of Electronic Public Utilities," *Journal of Law and Humanities*, Volume 14, Issue 1, Ziane Achour University, Algeria, 2021.
(3)- Oriol Mir, "Artificial Intelligence Law from an Administrative Law Perspective," *European Journal of Risk Regulation*, Volume 16, 2025.
(4)- Al-Karrar Habib Jahloul and Hussam Abis Awda, "Civil Liability for Damages Caused by Robots," *Al-Imam Al-Kadhim College*, *Al-Tareeq Journal for Education and Social Sciences*, Volume 6, Issue 5, May 2019.
(5) Hussam Rashid Hadi, "The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on International Relations," *Al-Jazeera Center for Strategic Studies*, Doha, Issue 20, November 2023.
(6) -Hussein Mustafa Rasoul and Shaheen Hassan Muhammad Azzi, The extent of determining the administration’s responsibility based on the service error, a research paper published in the Iraqi University Journal, Issue 66, Volume 3, 2024
(7) Duaa Jalil Hatem, Artificial Intelligence and International Smart Criminal Liability, Al-Mufakker Journal, University of Baghdad, College of Law and Political Science, Issue 18, February 2019.
(8) Reem Ali Mohammed Al-Rabghi, Digital Government in Light of Digital Transformation Programs and Achieving the Objectives of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia's Vision 2030: The Digital Government Authority as a Model, International Journal of Information Technology and Data, Volume 2, Issue 2, July 2022.
(9) Taha Amr Mohammed Badawi, The Legal System of Smart Robots Equipped with Artificial Intelligence Technology (The United Arab Emirates as a Model), Journal of Legal and Economic Studies, Volume 7, Issue 2, University Center of Barika, Algeria.
(10) Abdulaziz Mohammed Hamad Saati, Governance Rules and Monitoring Compliance with Laws and Their Role in Promoting Good Governance, Security and Law Journal, Dubai, Issue 2, 2022.
(11)Atwi Samira, Issawi Nadia, E-Government as a Tool for Improving Public Service with Reference to the Experience of Some Public Service Institutions in the United States of America, Journal of Human Research and Studies, Volume 11, Issue 14, University of Constantine, Algeria, July 29, 2017.
(12) Fahd Saeed Al-Dhahouri, Administrative Liability for the Use of Artificial Intelligence Based on Error, University of Sharjah Journal of Legal Sciences, Volume 1, Issue 1, 2024.
(13) Muhammad Irfan Al-Khatib, The Legal Status of Humanoid Robots: A Reading of the Rules in Civil Law for Robots of 2017 (Problems and Challenges: A Comparative Study), Kuwait International Law School Journal, Issue 24, Year 6, December 2018.
(14)Mahmoud Salama Abdel Moneim Sharif, Criminal Liability of Humanoid Robots: A Comparative Study, an article published in the Arab Journal of Forensic Science and Forensic Medicine, Naif Arab University for Security Sciences, Issue 13, 2020.
(15) Muhammad Al-Tamimi, Criminal Liability Arising from Autonomous Vehicle Accidents Leadership: A Comparative Study, Journal of Law, Kuwait University, Educational Publishing Council, Volume 44, Issue 4, 2022.
(16) - Musa Ahmed Jamal Al-Din, Economics of Governance: A Study in the Legal, Political, and Economic Foundations of Governance, Kuwait International Law School Journal, Special Supplement 1, Part 1, May 1, 2006.
Laws
- The Iraqi Constitution of 2005
- The Iraqi Penal Code No. (111) of 1969, as amended
- The State Council Law No. 65 of 1979, as amended
- The Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951
- The Compulsory Motor Vehicle Insurance Law No. (52) of 1980
- The Iraqi Electronic Signature and Electronic Transactions Law No. (78) of 2012
- The Iraqi Traffic Law No. (8) of 2019.
Foreign Laws
- European Law No. (1689/2024) issued by the European Parliament and the Council on 13 June 2024, the "European Artificial Intelligence Act" (EU AI Act).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Journal of Al-Farahidi's Arts

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.